AI Impact on Developers – Will Humans' Ability to Code Atrophy?
April 17, 2024

Kathleen McKnight and Vinay Bhola
KS&R

As researchers focused on the technology industry, we commonly examine the perceptions that different roles have about emerging technology. We've been monitoring perceptions of Artificial intelligence (AI) for over a decade and early on we hypothesized that developers might be skeptical and have a difficult time trusting AI. We were wrong, developers commonly look to their community for help with coding techniques, troubleshooting issues and sharing insights.

Over the years we've seen increased openness from developers towards AI because of its ability to serve some of the same purposes that they have turned to sources like Stack Overflow, GitHub, Reddit and other online forums and communities in the past.

Developers are enthusiastic about the opportunities that AI presents for automating tasks, generating code snippets, and reducing development time. AI can even improve code quality by providing suggestions for code improvements and ensuring adherence to coding standards and best practices.

While AI has already made many strides in what it is capable of in the field of development, AI models rely heavily on data for training and validation. Outputs may only be as helpful as the underlying data; if it hasn't been trained on code examples for the task at hand or in the desired language, it won't be much assistance. AI also can lack transparency or have the potential to amplify biases present in training data, making it difficult for developers to understand or rely upon the recommendations coming out of AI.

"I use AI a lot and it helps me write better code. It's only useful if it is very familiar with the programming language."(Reddit)

"The AI improves coding efficiency, many professional programmers have stated as much. Better AI would improve it even more." (Reddit)

Some developers have expressed concerns about job displacement with some saying it will take away the need for coding as it exists today.

"AI will kill coding like compilers killed programmers."(Reddit)

More likely AI will create a shift in developer's roles. New opportunities that didn't exist before will arise for developers who incorporate AI into their projects and focus on AI technology itself. Those developers with specialized skills focused on machine learning, natural language processing and data science are likely to be in even greater demand. AI also brings with it new prospects for developer collaboration with those in adjacent fields like data science, math, and ethics.

Corporations have been looking to low-code/no-code platforms for years in the attempt to enable those without extensive coding knowledge to do part of the job of a developer in theory. But as AI continues to mature, will companies rely more and more on the coding content generated by AI and downplay the need for human problem-solving skills and innovation?

Currently the common sentiment is that human review, assistance, and guidance from experienced developers is needed to evaluate code that is generated by AI.

"AI, even good AI is unreliable because it doesn't make something good, it makes something that looks good, regardless of if it works or not. Plus, code always needs debugging and updating. Scrutiny is something humans are particularly good at." (Reddit)

Today, there are plenty of experienced coders who can evaluate and bring insight to how — and how not to — incorporate the code being generated by AI. However, as reliance on AI code generation perpetuates, will we see a decline in human coding capabilities?

Similarly, without developers honing their skills on the rigor of basic coding will they lose their understanding of the intricacies that allow them to create elegant and innovative solutions?

There is a risk of developers becoming overly dependent on AI, which could lead to a decline in new ideas and problem-solving abilities. To avoid this, it is important for developers and the companies that employ them to continue to view AI as a complement to existing skills, rather than a replacement and actively engage in continuous learning rather than seeing AI as a means to time and cost savings in the future.

Kathleen McKnight is VP and Principal at KS&R and Vinay Bhola is a KS&R Associate
Share this

Industry News

April 29, 2024

Code Intelligence announced a new feature to CI Sense, a scalable fuzzing platform for continuous testing.

April 29, 2024

WSO2 is adding new capabilities for WSO2 API Manager, WSO2 API Platform for Kubernetes (WSO2 APK), and WSO2 Micro Integrator.

April 29, 2024

OpenText™ announced a solution to long-standing open source intake challenges, OpenText Debricked Open Source Select.

April 29, 2024

ThreatX has extended its Runtime API and Application Protection (RAAP) offering to provide always-active API security from development to runtime, spanning vulnerability detection at Dev phase to protection at SecOps phase of the software lifecycle.

April 29, 2024

Canonical announced the release of Ubuntu 24.04 LTS, codenamed “Noble Numbat.”

April 25, 2024

JFrog announced a new machine learning (ML) lifecycle integration between JFrog Artifactory and MLflow, an open source software platform originally developed by Databricks.

April 25, 2024

Copado announced the general availability of Test Copilot, the AI-powered test creation assistant.

April 25, 2024

SmartBear has added no-code test automation powered by GenAI to its Zephyr Scale, the solution that delivers scalable, performant test management inside Jira.

April 24, 2024

Opsera announced that two new patents have been issued for its Unified DevOps Platform, now totaling nine patents issued for the cloud-native DevOps Platform.

April 23, 2024

mabl announced the addition of mobile application testing to its platform.

April 23, 2024

Spectro Cloud announced the achievement of a new Amazon Web Services (AWS) Competency designation.

April 22, 2024

GitLab announced the general availability of GitLab Duo Chat.

April 18, 2024

SmartBear announced a new version of its API design and documentation tool, SwaggerHub, integrating Stoplight’s API open source tools.

April 18, 2024

Red Hat announced updates to Red Hat Trusted Software Supply Chain.

April 18, 2024

Tricentis announced the latest update to the company’s AI offerings with the launch of Tricentis Copilot, a suite of solutions leveraging generative AI to enhance productivity throughout the entire testing lifecycle.